PHILOSOPHICAL EXPERIMENT AND SCIENTIFIC EXPERIMENT IN GABRIEL MARCEL

Authors

  • Victor Xavier PUC-PR Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.71263/s11ezh33

Keywords:

Problema e Mistério, Ser e ter, Espírito de Curiosidade e Espírito de Inquietude

Abstract

To talk about the philosophical experience and the philosophical experiment in Marcel, it is necessary to remember very suggestive themes that help to understand the man of the twenty-first century. The first of them is a problem and mystery that in the midst of the technicist, consumerist and utilitarian vision that we live today, it seems to be complicated to understand something as being a mystery. Therefore, Marcel divides this issue well. For him, the problem is part of the first reflection, while the mystery is part of the second reflection. This reduction of mystery to problem is, in fact, a very characteristic of today's world, in which there is objectification of everything, including man himself, thus being immersed in the society of the disposable. Therefore, the human being is a piece, a number. Looking at social networks is realizing that it doesn't matter who is behind the screens, but the number of followers of the profile. Man cannot be just that. The problem carries with it the need for a solution. Therefore, being, in this perspective, is something that can only accomplish what technique accomplishes. This is governed by immanence, but it cannot be forgotten that it is also a mystery. There is an existential perspective from the incarnated being and, thus, the dimension of transcendence also prevails. Being is not an object and, therefore, needs an approximation of conduct faithful to being. This reflection leads to the next topic, which is the difference and the relationship between being and having, which is a theme that is still widely commented on today, even though it is so little understood and much less reflected on with the seriousness that is due to it, as did the French philosopher who is the basis of this article. Always when one thinks of this paradox of being and having, one thinks of what one has and what one is. It cannot be denied that having has generated a very large emptiness in people, with appearance prevailing over reality. The fact is that society has reduced man to being to having. It is not strange nor is it a new thought when it is said that having is in the realm of technique, of objectivity and the more one has, the more one wants to have: a situation that has led man to despair and anguish, for not having everything that consumerism produces. In Marcel, to philosophize is to insistently seek being. If, in the first reflection, he presents the degradation of the being, in the second reflection he reveals and restores his degraded, because for him what matters most is to relate the being to the existence, the being always being the potency, the power of existence. He is always the one who has traveled, the one who is traveling and the one who still wants to achieve. Closing with two themes that are interconnected to what was written: spirit of curiosity and spirit of restlessness. As already mentioned, Marcel insists on the dimension of reflection of the human being, which is a striking characteristic of so many philosophers of the past. Finally, he does not fail to insist that the true philosophy is the one that the Greeks lived in antiquity, which is the fruit of astonishment and not just of mere curiosity, which is a characteristic of philosophy today. Thus, in philosophical experience and scientific experiment, Marcel makes it clear that human restlessness reinforces and sustains the higher life of the spirit, while human curiosity paralyzes it.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

ARAÚJO SILVA, Marcos Érico; CAMINHA, Iraquitan. A filosofia concreta de Gabriel Marcel: por uma filosofia da história da filosofia e uma filosofia do ensino da filosofia. Trilhas Filosóficas, Caicó, ano 12, n. 3, Edição Especial, 2019, p. 169-184. Dossiê em Comemoração aos 130 anos do Nascimento de Gabriel Marcel.

AZEVEDO, J. A. Do cogito ao credo: a filosofia de Gabriel Marcel como preambulum fidei. Trilhas Filosóficas, Caicó, ano 12, n. 3, Edição Especial, 2019, p. 61-81. Dossiê em Comemoração aos 130 anos do Nascimento de Gabriel Marcel.

AZEVEDO, J. A.. O Mistério da Encarnação em Gabriel Marcel. Argumentos, Ano 2, Nº 4, 2010.

BEATO, J. M. Encarnação, atestação e esperança: Paul Ricoeur, leitor de Gabriel Marcel. Universidade de Coimbra, 2016.

BECKER, Julci Stefano. Gabriel Marcel e a formação na perspectiva do ser. (Dissertação de Mestrado). Ijuí: Editora Unijuí, 2007.

CARMONA, F. B. La filosofia de Gabriel Marcel: de la dialéctica a la invocacción. Madri: Encuentro, 1988.

GARAUDY, Roger. Perspectivas do homem: existencialismo, pensamento católico e marxismo. Rio de Janeiro: Civilização Brasileira, 1965.

GOMES, Paulo de Tarso. Gabriel Marcel: A filosofia da existência como Neo-Socratismo. Artigo apresentado a Reflexão, Campinas, 32 (91). p. 11-17, jul./dez., 2007.

LARROYO, Francisco. Pedagogia Existencial. In: História Geral da Pedagogia. São Paulo: Editor Mestre Jou, 1970, p. 869-874.

MARCEL, Gabriel. L’Iconoclaste. Paris: Stock, 1923.

MARCEL, Gabriel. Journal Métaphysique. Paris: Gallimard, 1927.

MARCEL, Gabriel. Être et avoir. Paris: Aubier/Montaigne, 1935.

MARCEL, Gabriel. Position et approches concrètes du mystère ontologique. Paris: Vrin, 1949.

MARCEL, Gabriel. Os homens contra o homem. Porto: Editora Educação Nacional, 1951.

MARCEL, Gabriel. El Mistério del Ser. Buenos Aires: Editorial Sudamericana, 1953.

MARCEL, Gabriel. El Hombre Problemático. Buenos Aires: Editorial Sudamericana, 1956.

MARCEL, Gabriel. Homo Viator: prolegomenes a une metaphysique de l’esperance. Paris: Aubier-Montaigne, 1963.

MARCEL, Gabriel. Diário Metafísico. Madrid: Ediciones Guadarrama, 1969.

MARCEL, Gabriel. Les hommens contre l’humain. Préface de Paul Ricoeur. Paris: Edições Universitaires, 1991.

MARCEL, Gabriel. Entretiens: Paul Ricoeur, Gabriel Marcel. Paris: Présence de Gabriel Marcel, 1998.

MARCEL, Gabriel. Essai de philosophie concrète. Paris: Gallimard, 1999.

MARÍAS, Julián. História da filosofia. Prólogo de Xavier Zubiri; epílogo de José Ortega y Gasset; tradução Claudia Berliner; revisão técnica Franklin Leopoldo e Silva. São Paulo: Martins Fontes, 2004.

MOUNIER, Emmanuel. Introdução aos existencialismos. São Paulo: Livraria duas Cidades, 1963.

NÉDONCELLE, M. “Préface et notes.” In (Euvres philosophiques de Newman). Paris: Aubier, 1945.

NIETZSCHE, F. Fragmentos póstumos. Trad. Oswaldo Giacóia Jr. Campinas, SP: IFCH/Unicamp, Abril/1996, nº22, p. 3-29 [Série Textos Didáticos].

PEREIRA DE GÓMES, Maria Nieves. Educação personalizada. Bauru-SP: EDUSC, 1997.

PRINI, Pietro. Gabriel Marcel et la méthodologie de l`invérifiable. Paris: Desclée de Brouwer, 1955.

RAMOS, S. R. V. Aprendizados de existência, filosofia e a formação humana: leituras Ricœurianas em torno de Marcel e Jaspers. Capítulo do Livro De filosofia e de filosofares: olhares e pensares sobre achados e acontecências, Goiânia-GO: Editora Phillos, 2020.

RICŒUR, P. Gabriel Marcel et Karl Jaspers – Philosophie du mystère et philosophie du paradoxe. Paris: Éditions du Temps Présent, 1947.

SILVA, Claudinei Aparecido de Freitas. “A mordedura do real’: Gabriel Marcel e o gesto transcendental”, in: FERRER, D. F.; UTTEICH, L. C. (Orgs.). A filosofia transcendental e a sua crítica: idealismo, fenomenologia e hermenêutica. Coimbra: Imprensa da Universidade de Coimbra/Coimbra University Press, 2015, p. 323-355.

SILVA, Claudinei Aparecido de Freitas. Problema ou Mistério? O estatuto da filosofia via Gabriel Marcel. In: Problemata: R. Intern. Fil. V. 9. n. 2 (2018), p. 188-205.

STEFANELLO, Antoninho Pegoraro. O homem, um ser em trânsito - perspectiva de Gabriel Marcel. (Dissertação de Mestrado). Santa Maria: UFSM, 1976.

TEIXEIRA, Joaquim de Sousa. A apologética filosófica de Gabriel Marcel. Didaskalia. Lisboa. 8:1, p. 55-88, 1978.

WITTGENSTEIN, L. Tratactus logico-philosophicus. Trad. Luiz H. L. Santos. 2 ed. São Paulo: Edusp, 1994.

ZILLES, U. Gabriel Marcel e o Existencialismo. Porto Alegre: Ed. PUCRS/Acadêmica, 1988.

Published

2025-05-02

How to Cite

Xavier, V. (2025). PHILOSOPHICAL EXPERIMENT AND SCIENTIFIC EXPERIMENT IN GABRIEL MARCEL. Re(senhas), 2(2), e25024. https://doi.org/10.71263/s11ezh33